Canada’s Emerging Indigenous Right’s Framework

59 posts / 0 new
Last post
epaulo13 epaulo13's picture

Changes are afoot among First Nations

A few weeks ago, Romeo Saganash, the NDP member of Parliament for Abitibi-Baie James-Nunavik-Eeyou dropped an f-bomb in the House of Commons. He was clearly frustrated with the Liberals’ determination to proceed with the Trans Mountain pipeline despite First Nations opposition.

“Why doesn’t the prime minister just say the truth and tell Indigenous peoples that he doesn’t give a f**k about their rights?” he asked the stunned members of the House of Commons.

Of course, he was called out by the Speaker and told to apologize, which he did in French. Saganash is trilingual and fluent in Cree, English and French. The prime minister wasn’t in the house at the time, but you can be sure he heard all about it.

However, social media lit up with First Nations people supporting his use of bad language and championing his cause. He has become one more hero in Indian Country.

This little incident is an example of the change that is occurring in Indian Country. The old guard in the Assembly of First Nations and the regional organizations like the FSIN have been eclipsed by independent leaders that appeal more to the young, politically motivated members of the Indigenous community.

Dr. Pam Palmater is an associate professor at Ryerson University who travels the country speaking out on issues of First Nations rights and governance. She is also a regular panellist on the CBC. I once saw her destroy a member of the Taxpayers Federation. She gave no quarter and attacked the very existence of his organization.

Senator Murray Sinclair and Wilton Littlechild are two keen legal minds who led the discussions and action related to reconciliation. They continue as moral leaders and appear regularly on panels and at speaking engagements across the country.

Cindy Blackstock persisted in the legal fight to have the government recognize the serious underfunding in child welfare and by extension all First Nations social and educational programs. She was the public face of an eight-year battle with the government. Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada even conducted surveillance on her, barring her from meetings and spying on her Facebook page.

There was a time when we had very few spokespeople. In the postwar period when our leaders began to organize in earnest, many First Nations didn’t have chiefs. The Indian Agent ran the whole show. It therefore became a political act to elect a chief and council that could speak on behalf of the people.

The emphasis was on the chiefs and they spoke out demanding better living conditions and the recognition of our treaty rights. The federal Indian Affairs department regarded the provincial organizations as a dangerous fifth column. To counter political government, the department dumped government programs on the First Nations. The first program to be transferred was welfare, which was the worst for the government to administer.

The chief and council became administrators for the government and cemented the neocolonial system.

Over the years the chiefs and their organizations have become compromised and are now the administrators for their people. They are stuck with a system that underfunded and over-regulated.

At one time leaders such as Harold Cardinal, George Manuel, David Ahenakew and Noel Starblanket commanded respect and had the ear of their people and government.

Perry Bellegarde, the National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, is now seen as too close to the federal government and Justin Trudeau in particular. His stand on the Trans Mountain pipelines is vague in comparison to the militant opposition from Pam Palmater and Mohawk activist Russell Diabo.

epaulo13 epaulo13's picture

Treaty Nations Reject Canada's Proposed Indigenous Rights Recognition and Implementation Framework

At an Alberta Assembly of Treaty Chiefs meeting many Treaty Nations have stated their opposition to Canada's proposed Indigenous Rights and Recognition Framework Legislation. We are Treaty Tribes, Nations and Peoples of Treaty No. 6 (1876 and adhesions thereto), Treaty No. 8 and Tsuu T'ina, Treaty No. 7.  Several Treaty Chiefs have sent letters to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to ensure that the positions of Treaty Nations is on record regarding rejection of Canada's Proposed Indigenous Rights Recognition and Implementation Framework.  The letters are in response to Minister Carolyn Bennett's public message, "No stopping the framework, says Minister Bennett, but she's listening (October 29, 2018)."  "The First Nations have made it known publicly and in writing that Canada's aggressive agenda to expedite plans to create legislation designed to deny our rights to lands and resources have been done all without our Free Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC).  This does not bring Honour to the Crown," Chief Craig Makinaw.

"Our sacred treaty matters were not addressed – instead the Minister in July of 2018 sent out a form letter that completely mischaracterized the process and did not include one word on the treaty issues raised in our letter. Onion Lake was not the only Nation to send a letter against the process.  Canada has chosen to ignore those letters resorting to fabrications," stated Okimaw Henry Lewis.

There was an expedited engagement period for the Framework process, and the results contained in the roll-up documents were selective in nature, supporting only Canada's pre-determined positions and goals and were dispensed only at federally pre-selected and managed meetings, and not released to our Nations.

Chief Kurt Burnstick has stated:  "As Treaty Peoples, Canada always must bring the honour of the Crown into dealings with our Nations. The present process is full of sharp dealings that bring no honour to either the Crown or the state of Canada."

"The Framework is in direct conflict with our Treaty, inherent rights and title.   The process does not recognize nor respect our jurisdiction," stated Chief Tony Alexis.

"It is clear for our First Nations that continuing with this process will result in a major set-back for the renewal of the relationship between Canada and Treaty First Nations," stated Chief Billy Morin....


Since 'Canada's Emerging Indigenous Rights' Framework' is largely based on 'fraud, treason and genocide', it's probably best to post this here. A book that will help to put things right amidst so much that is wrong.

Bruce Clark: Ongoing Genocide Caused By Judicial Suppression of the 'Existing' Aboriginal Rights

See also 'About The Pipeline'....


this could go in the legal marijuana thread too. put it here though because it was a given FN would get involved. i hope it incorporates back into our7 culture now.


Kanahus Manuel on Canada's administrative units of colonial control

"When we say 'chief and council' we mean 'colonization'."

Canada needs to hear this.

epaulo13 epaulo13's picture


Just over 500 Indigenous people from communities all across Ontario came together to hear the youth, speakers, Chiefs, and many others to say in one voice to Stop The Framework.


epaulo13 epaulo13's picture

..a good overview of the framework and the current state of affairs.

Our people are demanding fundamental change says Russ Diabo

Unless there is significant change in the lives of First Nations people, Russ Diabo says there will be more push back from the people.

“Our people are increasingly demanding fundamental change, not incremental change,” Diabo said on Tuesday’s edition of Face to Face with Host Dennis Ward. “And they’re continuing to act on it at a local level.”


What Can Humanity Learn From the Great Law of Peace (and vid)

"Stuart Myiow, Wolf Clan representative of the Mohawk Traditional Council, says Western 'democracies' wrongly prioritize individual rights over the rights of the collective."