Anti-Prostitution Pledge Heads to Supreme Court

3 posts / 0 new
Last post
susan davis
Anti-Prostitution Pledge Heads to Supreme Court

Anti-Prostitution Pledge Heads to Supreme Court

Melissa Gira Grant on April 19, 2013 - 4:22 PM ET

On Monday, the Supreme Court hears oral arguments in a case that will decide if recipients of government aid can be forced to oppose prostitution—or potentially any other issue as a contingency of receiving US funds. The case, Alliance for Open Society International v. United States Agency for International Development, arises from a controversial policy governing AIDS education, prevention and treatment, a decade-long fight that's crossed political lines and was kicked off by Representative Chris Smith as part of a larger conservative attempt to undermine reproductive and sexual health care. With HIV and AIDS projects facing closure if they don't adopt the government's position on sex work, it's sex workers who are paying the ultimate price.

From the onset of the global AIDS epidemic, sex workers have been scapegoated for the spread of HIV—sometimes even by those who claim to help them. Around the globe, AIDS provided an excuse to close red light districts and step up enforcement of anti-prostitution laws. In one early example, in 1988, California considered a bill to forcibly test all people arrested for prostitution-related charges for HIV. If positive, they could face felony charges. Fears, myths and stigma—fueled by a lack of HIV education and a refusal among policymakers to consider the reality of the epidemic—have historically made sex workers, along with gay and bisexual men and injection-drug users, an easy target. 

Now, over thirty years into the epidemic, with that much more evidence available on the social and structural factors that drive HIV, policy still lags life-threateningly behind. One such policy is embedded in what's regarded as the United States' cornerstone AIDS policy, PEPFAR (the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief). Passed into law in 2003 under President George W. Bush, PEPFAR has moved approximately $46 billion to programs working to prevent and treat HIV. But if your HIV program supports sex workers? You could find yourself denied funding and your doors shut.

Issues Pages: 
kropotkin1951 kropotkin1951's picture

Interesting issue thanks for sharing. I only wish you had specified the US Supreme Court in the title for this thread.

susan davis

sorry, i guess i should have specified. i just copied the title of the article.

it is relevant for sex workers everywhere however as the anti prostitution oath has impacted workers all over the planet. it is an important step in the global battle for sex workers rights.

i remember at the international harm reduction conference, a russian researcher presented evidence that female sex workers were responsible for the spread of HIV in russia and that there were no gay men in russia....needless to say, we challenged her findings...